Displaced Voices: A Journal of Migration, Archives and Cultural Heritage

LGBTQI+ Refugees and the Gap Between Refugee Protection Law and Reality

Thomars Shamuyarira

Displaced Voices: A Journal of Migration, Archives & Cultural Heritage

Abstract

Seventy-five years after the adoption of the 1951 Refugee Convention, the global refugee protection system remains the cornerstone of international responses to displacement. The Convention established the legal definition of a refugee and introduced key protections, including the principle of non-refoulement, intended to ensure that people fleeing persecution are not returned to danger. While these commitments have shaped international refugee law, the lived experiences of many displaced people reveal a persistent gap between legal protection and practical reality. This article examines that gap through the experiences of LGBTQI+ refugees in Africa, with a particular focus on South Africa. Although South Africa is often recognised for its progressive constitutional protections for sexual orientation and gender identity, I show that queer and trans refugees frequently encounter systemic barriers to safety, documentation, housing, and healthcare. The discussion illustrates that administrative backlogs, limited access to asylum procedures, and social hostility leave many individuals in prolonged legal limbo, unable to access the protection the law promises. At the same time, South Africa has signalled its intention to withdraw from the Refugee Convention and re-enter with reservations, including the possible removal of the principle of non-refoulement and the adoption of a “first safe country” rule. This raises urgent questions for queer and trans refugees, particularly on a continent where many states continue to criminalise homosexuality and do not legally recognise transgender identities. Drawing on the work of the refugee-led organisation they founded in 2016, The Fruit Basket (TFB), they explore how grassroots initiatives have stepped in to address these gaps by providing emergency support, safe housing, community education, and human rights documentation for displaced LGBTQI+ individuals. The case study illustrates both the resilience of refugee communities and the structural limitations of existing protection systems. The article argues that refugee protection frameworks must move beyond formal legal commitments and engage more directly with the lived realities of displaced people whose identities place them at the intersection of multiple vulnerabilities. Recognising and supporting refugee-led responses is essential if international protection systems are to remain relevant in an increasingly complex landscape of displacement.

Share This Article

Shamuyarira, T. (2026) ‘LGBTQI+ Refugees and the Gap Between Refugee Protection Law and Reality’, Displaced Voices: A Journal Of Migration, Archives And Cultural Heritage, 5(1), pp. 52–61.

Type Article
Information DOI: tbc
Creative Commons  This is an Open Access article, distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution licence (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0), which permits unrestricted re-use, distribution and reproduction, provided the original article is properly cited.
Copyright © The Author(s), 2026. Published by the Living Refugee Archive.